Flowers, part 2

A commenter on a post about the Flora Expo on Michael Turton’s blog pointed out that the decision to host the Expo and the date were determined way back in the Ma administration, not in the Hao administration.  (Thanks M)  So I searched a bit on the Taipei City government website, and, lo and behold, there are news releases in early 2006 listing November 2010 as the date the exhibition would open.  I had not known this.  And the wheels in my head started turning…

I wondered why in the world Hao would schedule such a high-risk event to open right before the election.  In fact, he didn’t do any such thing.  Ma did it to him.  Why would Ma do such a thing?

Ma was certainly aware of the timing, but I doubt he would have worried about it so much.  After all, he wasn’t going to be running for re-election during the Expo.  Hao would be (and by early 2006, he could be reasonably sure that Hao would be the next mayor), but that was Hao’s problem.  Anyway, the KMT candidate should be able to win in Taipei City, right?

Maybe this was just good public policy.  For one thing, Taiwan doesn’t host many international events, so this could be one way to raise Taiwan’s international profile.  Well, I guess no one is against raising Taiwan’s international profile, but I am skeptical about whether this (or the World Games in Kaohsiung or the Deaf Olympics etc.) will have much impact.  Can you tell me who the last country to host the International Flora Expo (or the World Games etc) was?  What about all the tourism money that this will bring in.  Again, I’m skeptical.  Even in really high profile international events such as the Olympics or the World Cup, most of the tickets are sold to citizens of the host country, not international tourists.  Are you aware of many groups of international flower lovers who have circled these dates on their calendars and are planning to make a special trip to Taiwan to see all the flowers?  I’m not.  I could be wrong on this, but I’m guessing that the overwhelming majority of tickets will be bought by ROC nationals.  Well, what about the cultural aspect to this?  Isn’t it nice that the city government is holding a flower festival?  Who hates flowers?[1] This will be nice for the residents of Taipei City.  I don’t disagree on this, though this seems like an awful lot of money for a flower festival aimed primarily at city residents.  If that were the purpose, they could do this much more frugally.

On the other hand, there is one group that has to be thrilled with the city’s decision to host the Flora Expo.  This group is the Taiwan flower industry.  Taiwan’s flower industry is quite large, and is the world leader in orchids.   In fact, flowers are one of Taiwan’s more important export agricultural products.  For a few months, Taiwan will be the center of the world’s flower industry, and Taiwanese growers will be able to show off their wares and make valuable business contacts.  The domestic boost in flower popularity should also be a boon to the industry.  And of course they will sell lots of merchandise to the Flora Expo itself.  There’s just one thing: not much of the flower industry is based in Taipei.  To my knowledge, the center of the Taiwanese flower industry is in southern Changhua County.  Why in the world would the Ma city government want to spend enormous amounts of money to curry favor with an industry based in central Taiwan?

Asking the question that way makes the answer obvious: to the extent that the decision to hold the Flora Expo was politically motivated, the goal was the 2008 (and perhaps 2012) presidential election, not the 2010 Taipei City mayoral election.  Central Taiwan is the great battleground that decides presidential elections.  Southern Changhua, in particular, is currently the place where the map turns from green to blue.[2] More generally, Ma needed to shore up his credentials with agricultural Taiwan.  In 2006, no one doubted that Ma could speak to urban sophisticates.  It was less clear that he would be able to get through to farmers.  Currying favor with the flower industry was a very smart move.  It may continue to pay dividends in 2012.

By the way, this doesn’t get Hao off the hook for the problems the Flora Expo is currently experiencing.  If the decision to hold the Expo in November had already been taken, the decisions to (a) fund it so generously, (b) treat it as his administration’s showpiece achievement, and (c) to award contracts in particular ways are entirely Hao’s.

[1] Uh, Frozen Garlic isn’t crazy about flowers.

[2] Yes, I know that geography doesn’t matter in presidential elections.  Votes count the same whether they are cast in Jinmen or Tainan.  Still, this can be a useful way of thinking about how to build a winning coalition.

Tags: , ,

5 Responses to “Flowers, part 2”

  1. Okami Says:

    Correct me if I’m wrong but wasn’t a change in Yunlin voting patterns a major factor in Chen beating Lien Zhan and Song? I remember reading that it was a major switch in their voting patterns that narrowly gave Chen the lead.

    Might this also be the reason for putting major industrial projects in southern Changhua which doesn’t have enough fresh water? It seems like a long term strategy by the KMT. I could of course be very wrong.

  2. frozengarlic Says:

    There was indeed a big shift in Yunlin in 2004. It happened all up and down the south-central coast, which you might think of as the center of traditional Min-nan society, but it was more pronounced in Yunlin than almost anywhere else.

    As for the industrial projects as a vote-winning strategy, I am dubious. The Formosa Plastics complex next door has arguably been one of the catalysts in Yunlin’s astounding transformation from a KMT stronghold to a DPP dominated area over the past decade. The local politicians will certainly have more money to throw around, but voters can just look across the river to judge whether this is a good deal for them over the long run. On the other hand, KMT politicians might be convinced that the hike in land prices and cornucopia of jobs will make this a political winner.

    If you are talking about industrial projects other than the petrochemical one, then maybe so. Everyone wants the Volkswagen and Ford factories. But I think their eventual location will be more a result of tax breaks, land availability, and company preferences than the KMT’s electoral needs.

  3. Okami Says:

    Nice to see you posting again btw, as good as Turton without all the liberal wackiness. 😉

    I think the KMT mistakes these large projects as vote getters because it used to work that way and they have had a reputation as economic developers(however mistaken that is). I think the KMT leadership’s ideas of what Taiwanese want and what Taiwanese want are seriously out of synch. Most Taiwanese can easily get a job and they also don’t want to work in a factory.

    I think the problem with Yunlin was that people saw very clearly how political capital helped a large company to their detriment while they must slog through the bureaucracy that often doesn’t even know the very basics of its job despite garnering better benefits and pay than private sector workers.

    Just off of my feelings, I’d say Su will be the next mayor of Taipei city. I think people will take a look around and realize just how much Chen changed the character of Taipei and made the place livable. I’m just wondering how he can improve Taipei as Chen picked most of the low hanging fruit.

  4. frozengarlic Says:

    Nothing wrong with wackiness.

    Taipei did change a lot during the Chen years, though I doubt that his performance will continue to make new converts over a decade later. The biggest change was the opening of all the MRT lines, which transformed Taipei traffic. The next mayor will also preside over the opening of several lines, but I don’t think the change will be quite as dramatic.

  5. Jamb Says:

    The Government Beautification expenditures are all siphoning money back to the KMT coffers. Where is the money going to? Just one shell company JOIN corp winning all the high contract bids so that the KMT and the gangsters can make MO money! Don’t ask the subcontractors for money because they get stiffed and go bankrupt.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: